RSS



Is Downloading Movies and Games Becoming a Legal Business?

Wed, Jul 22, 2009

Internet

Talk about it in our Forums

Is Downloading Movies and Games Becoming a Legal Business?

The rogue trade of file sharing or should I say illegal downloading of movies and games has been rife for years. So many pirate sites exist that allow P2P file transfer or access to news servers where header information points to the file server. It’s claimed that the movie industry alone loses millions of dollars each year to the trade. Though, what can be done to control it?

One answer might be to run deals by the pirate companies that legalize the trade so that downloading of games and movies is no problem for the production companies concerned. There are many companies that have done just that, not by bartering a deal with pirate companies, but by simply allowing people to download as much as they want for a subscription fee. This model seems to work, for example one called Metaboli allows you to download top game titles for just a small monthly fee.

Surely this is the answer. Subscription models that offer such a deal should drive people to simple cough up a small meager fee for the privilege of downloading what they want.

In April, it became apparent that Pirate Bay, a large file sharing company, was being bought by a Swedish software company called Global Gaming Factory X. Pirate Bay found itself facing huge litigation procedures that resulted in a one year jail term for its founders and paying millions in damages to the big boys of the industry such as Warner Bros and Sony Music. The argument has been raised that while this is good for the industry, it introduces a level of commercial control that sucks yet more freedom from the internet.

A report by the Guardian revealed that Pirate Bay made it public on their site:
“It’s time to invite more people into the project, in a way that is secure and safe for everybody. We need that, or the site will die. And letting TPB die is the last thing that is allowed to happen! “

The payment model may not be subscription based but rather like pay-per-view where users will pay for the files they want to access. One good side here is that users can also earn money by sharing their files. This will turn the file sharing industry into a mutually bound legal trade between the file sharing company and the consumer with content legally provided by the official distributors.

The business will commence in August once the final deliberations on how to manage the legal side of the business are concluded. The site will of course also attract advertising revenue.

There is speculation afoot already that it could fail due to what has happened to Napster’s falling subscriber base. Napster was shut down due to illegal music downloads and re-launched as a legal service in 2003. But ever since then, their subscriber base has been falling. Some may argue that this could be due to the lack of support in the industry for legalizing file sharing services.

Mr Pandeya representing the Swedish company told the Wall Street Journal at WSJ.com:
“We have plenty of investors who want to join this project,” he said. “Raising the capital won’t be a major issue.”

If the Pirate Bay site does re-launch as a legal business, could this be just the start of a more successful trend to legalize the whole file sharing business? Only time will tell, and the cooperation from investors. Perhaps there are too many servers available now to gain control though this move towards controlling a large operation like Pirate Bay is a shining new start.

Popularity: 7% [?]

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • MisterWong
  • Reddit
  • Technorati
  • BlinkList
  • Facebook
  • Fark
  • Mixx
  • Slashdot

This post was written by:

arsgeek - who has written 1980 posts on ArsGeek.


Contact the author

32 Comments For This Post

  1. Gaurav Says:

    Pirate bay has been raided number of times. But till now has managed to escape through legal loopholes. It is so since it don’t violet Swedish Laws and doesn’t come under preview of American laws. I think as like Interpol there must be a similar organisation which can operate on a global jurisdiction to effectively tackle international piracy of digital materials done via internet.

  2. amaryadav Says:

    Thanks for the info- it turns out Microsoft’s bing really is making an impact, it seems to me your blog is getting a lot of search engine traffic from bing- have you found this to be the case?

  3. gurgle Says:

    I do get the feeling some foreign laws will enable loop holes, perhaps rightly so. Sites like rapidshare and megaupload pretty much thrive on illegal activity, making only half-bothered efforts to clear up of such material. It will be interesting to see how things develop!

  4. jfml Says:

    i don’t think that subscriptions will be the answer on the long run. nor pay per view. both systems are limited to what one site can offer and no one is going to register on multiple sites just to get everyting they want, because it’s expensive and a pain in the a.s.s.

    i think in the end the only solution is to allow people to download whatever they want from whereever they want when they pay a monthly/yearly fee. the collected money than needs to be distributed to the artists (this will cut out most of the music- and movie-distributing people that’s why they are not so happy with this).

    the thinking about how this might be organized (how do figure out a more or less cheat-free way which artist is getting how much money) is just starting and it will probably take a long time until we have a system up and running because it has to be legalized by the law over the whole world. this model is called »kulturflatrate« (= »culture-flatrate) in germany.

    for further information:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xba2avAUZ8M
    http://www.eff.org/

  5. Slider Says:

    We also work in content sphere and we are also affended on unligal usage of our content… but people in Europe and USA rather buy something than still it.

  6. Slider Says:

    good article, tnx

  7. jaded_77 Says:

    Very interesting site, many thoughts are close to me, thanks you for your work and interesting article

  8. Digital Music Distribution Says:

    This is a quite interesting idea. Im not too sure if it is becoming legal, but it is moving away from piracy and to better products. Music it is Spotify leading the way.

  9. Vig Says:

    once again content is the king, but free stuff great content would be a great traffic magnet.

  10. Wedding Function Venues Says:

    Earlier downloading games and movies are not the legal thing. Now-a-days its become Legal Business, people pay some monthly rental to download the games and movies. That is the nice idea to enhance the business.

  11. 18 Oyunlar Says:

    thank you for post…

  12. collect bag Says:

    it is a goooooooooooooooood post
    thanks for share

  13. Lexus Says:

    good article, tnx

  14. Watch movies Says:

    I like Your Website theme and would like to know where to download it.Thank.

  15. Kelvin Says:

    In China, some popular Search Engine like sogou.com provide services for free download of song.

  16. aka_le_Mulder Says:

    Lar$ Ulrich… Napster… This is where it started from.
    I really think all those big daddies on top should be less greedy for money. They earn billions of dollar and it is still not enough.

  17. Davar@ Elevator Accident Lawyer Says:

    I think games must be free to download for all like open source software.

  18. doinggo Says:

    Do you have encountered such situations:Have many of DVDs,especially some favorite,however you don’t know how to enjoy them on your portable devices or other hard disc.Such as on iPhone, iPhone 3G, Sony PSP, PS3, YouTube (web), iRiver PMP, Archos and PMPs;And also don’t know how to share them on the Youtube,myspace etc.
    Well before I also met these issues,through my friends recommended,I knew the powerfulDVD Ripper for Mac.This kind of conversion software can help you solve above problems.In addition
    to this,It provides you a series of powerful and easy to use movie edit functions such as triming,cropping frame size,merging,adjustin effect,choosing subtitle,etc.
    So if you have the same trouble,I really hope my recommendation can help you.

  19. vitrier Says:

    french law hadopi now allows music companys to ban from internet provider everyone without justification…

  20. ipad transfer Says:

    iPad Transfer
    You need to have a try.
    You need this one.

  21. Andy jack Says:

    Hi, you can try this site to download from rapidshare

  22. Malcom Delbo Says:

    Explore & Have your iPad for Cost-free! -> http://bit.ly/cFBuis

  23. how to softmod Wii Says:

    They might as well just make it legal. I don’t think it’s really hurting anyone…

  24. Monica Stanko Says:

    Watch all the latestmovies here http://www.freemoviesforstreaming.co.cc

  25. Laurence Noggles Says:

    I’ve been coming your site for a while now. I really enjoy your writing style plus you provide terrific advice. Always keep up the good work!

  26. Katherine Says:

    Well you should check out piratebay website. there are emails by every company in the world with so many warnings. including Apple that msgd soo many times and Microsoft and Rockstar etc. But in reply they make fun of the writer and the threats! :D . Theyve been raided way many times.

  27. used Arizona cars Says:

    used Arizona cars Great ideas …. Thanks for sharing!

  28. buy ebooks Says:

    Hi bud would it be ok if we took some info from here to use on one of my sites? all the best

  29. deven Says:

    thanks a lot for your valuable sharing ,right from the beginning till end it was really very informative .i can witness the experience and steps you have taken to accomplish this wonderful work.

    Thanks and Regards

  30. 42 inch tv Says:

    Whew, definitely a controversial viewpoint!

  31. Ezequiel Zalk Says:

    “Me too! Love it! I was inspired when I was six *now 14* by Michael Imperioli, or Chris Moltisanti on ‘The Sopranos. I just love the subject of screenwriting!”

  32. BitPrize Says:

    The Google Inc., Owner of the YouTube, is in talks with major Hollywood studios about starting services of a paid online movies display.

1 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Culture-flatrate « jfml Says:

    [...] just read an article over at ArsGeek where the author was wondering how copyright infringement and illegal filesharing could be legalized. His suggestions where [...]

Leave a Reply